Rekey or Replace? A San Diego Property Manager’s Guide to Locks Between Tenants

Quick answer: California does not require landlords to rekey locks between tenants, but it does require working deadbolts and window locks, and most property managers rekey every unit at turnover. Rekey when the locks are in good shape and you only need the old keys to stop working. Replace them when they are worn, below code, or you want keypad or master key control.

Do California landlords have to rekey locks between tenants?

No state law requires a landlord to rekey after a tenant moves out. California does set minimum lock standards, though. Civil Code 1941.3 requires an operable deadbolt on each main swinging entry door, with a bolt that extends at least 13/16 of an inch beyond the strike edge when locked (older deadbolts of at least 1/2 inch are accepted). It also requires working locks on windows that are designed to open, and locks that meet fire and safety codes on exterior doors to common areas in multifamily buildings.

There is one case where changing locks is required on a deadline. Under Civil Code 1941.5, when a tenant gives the landlord qualifying documentation of abuse by someone who is not a tenant of the unit, the landlord must change the locks within 24 hours of the tenant’s written request.

Even without a law, rekeying at turnover is standard practice. A former tenant, their guests, a cleaner or a past contractor may still have a copy of the key, and a new tenant expects to be the only one who can open the door.

Rekey or replace: which one does the unit need?

Rekey when the locks work smoothly and meet code. We change the pins inside the cylinder so the old keys stop working and new keys are cut. The hardware stays on the door, so it is usually the faster and less expensive choice.

Replace when the lock is worn, sticks or is damaged, when the deadbolt does not meet the 13/16 inch throw, when you want a keypad deadbolt so you can change codes instead of keys, or when you are moving the building to a master key system or high-security keys that cannot be copied at a hardware store.

How a master key system saves property managers time

With a master key system, each tenant’s key opens only their own unit, while one master key opens every unit for maintenance and emergencies. When a tenant moves out, only that unit’s cylinder needs to be rekeyed, and the rest of the building stays the same. Restricted keyways add another layer, because new copies can only be made through the locksmith on file.

Turnover lock checklist for San Diego rentals

  • Collect every key, fob and garage remote from the outgoing tenant.
  • Rekey or replace the unit’s entry locks before the new tenant moves in.
  • Check that the entry deadbolt throws at least 13/16 of an inch.
  • Test the lock on every window that opens.
  • Check common-area doors and gates, and make sure door closers latch fully.
  • Update your key log with the new key numbers and who holds them.

Frequently asked questions

Is rekeying cheaper than replacing locks?

Usually, yes. Rekeying keeps the existing hardware and only changes the cylinder pins and keys. Replacing makes sense when the hardware itself is the problem or you want an upgrade.

Can a keypad deadbolt be rekeyed?

Most keypad deadbolts have a backup key cylinder that can be rekeyed, and the access code can be changed at every turnover. That makes them a popular choice for rentals.

Do you work with property management companies in San Diego?

Yes. Guy Z Locksmith and Security handles rekeys between tenants, master key systems, keypad deadbolts, door closers and gate locks for property managers and landlords across San Diego. We are licensed and bonded: California Locksmith License LCO #5103 and California Contractor License C-28 #1096644.

Have a turnover coming up? Call 619-892-7269 and we will schedule the rekey.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Check the current California Civil Code or ask your attorney about your specific property.